Who is the best 15 active QB's in the NFL today? Who knows? Is there a way you can figure this out? Is there an accurate way that you, I or any of us can compute this? I say yes and I also say that I done just that. That's right!!!!! The Realist has done it!!!! This is SUREFIRE!!!!! Aye......homers.......... feel me to look it over. Feel free to comment on it. This point system is based on there career achievements up until this point in their careers. The only thing that is up for debate is the playoff moments and if we remove that the only position that changes is Romo and Vick so feel free to try to check my formula. You can even feel free to openly dispute my list if necessary but I assure you one thing and one thing only:
I think with my MIND and not my HEART so you won't find any mistakes.
Categories- Points
Rings - 10
Super Bowl MVP - 8
Super Bowl Appearances - 2
Playoff Moments - 8
(Game Winning Drive in Playoffs/Superbowl, Mutual Agreed Upon Moment...... Ex...Peyton Manning Beating NE in AFC Championship, Rivers Beating Indy in OT or Vick in Lambeau)
League MVP - 6
Playoff Wins - 1
Criteria Seasons - 3
Playoffs with Criteria Season - 6
Pro Bowls - 1
NFL Passing Records – 1
Criteria Seasons
3700 or more yards, 62 Comp%, 26 or more TD's, 16 or less INT's (Add one int for each touchdown until you get to 20 then it is not considered a CS. Ex. -29 TD and 19 INT’s is still a CS. 30 and 20 is not.) Criteria Seasons w/playoffs (same stats but team makes playoffs)
* Note - Criteria seasons adjusted based on the era you played in. It is done by author discretion.
ALL PLAYERS
Montana – playoff wins (17-7), 3 Super Bowl MVP’s( 24 ), 4 Rings (40), 1 league MVP (6), 4 playoff moments (32), 6 passing records (6), 8 probowls (8), 4 super bowl appearances (8), 6 criteria season w/playoffs (36) – 177
Tom Brady - 3 rings (30), 2 Super Bowl MVP(16), 5 SB appearances(10), 2 playoff moments(16), 2 league MVP'S(12), playoff wins (17-7)(17) , 7 criteria seasons; 7 criteria seasons w/playoffs(42), 8 pro bowls(8), 20 passing records(20) - 171
Peyton Manning - 1 ring (10), 1 Super Bowl MVP(8), 2 appearances(4), 1 playoff moment(8), 4 league MVP'S(24) , playoff wins (9-11)(9), 11 criteria seasons; 11 criteria seasons w/playoffs(66), 11 pro bowls(11), 27 passing records(27) - 167
Favre – 1 Ring (10), 2 SB Appearances (4), 6 criteria seasons w playoffs (36), 11 time probowler (11), 3 time league MVP ( 18), playoff wins (13-11), 2 playoff moments (16), 7 passing records – 125
Elway – playoff wins (14-7), 1 Super Bowl MVP (8), 2 Rings (20), 1 league MVP (6), 4 playoff moments (32) , 5 Super bowl Appearances (10), 9 probowls (9), 4 criteria seasons, 2 w/playoffs (18), pasing records 5 - 122
Drew Brees - 1 ring (10), 1 Super Bowl MVP (8), 1 appearance (2), 1 playoff moment (8), playoff wins (5-4)(5), 6 criteria seasons; 4 criteria seasons w/playoffs(30) , 7 pro bowls(7), 38 passing records (38) - 108
Marino- 5 criteria seasons w/playoffs (30), 1 league mvp (6), 14 passing records (14), playoffs wins (8-9), 4 playoff moments (32) , SB appearances(2) - 93
Aaron Rodgers - 1 ring (10), 1 Super Bowl MVP(8), 1 appearance(2), 1 playoff moment (8), 1 league MVP(6), playoff wins (5-2)(5) , 5 criteria seasons; 4 criteria seasons w/playoffs (27), 2 pro bowls (2), 16 passing records(16) - 84
Troy Aikman - 3 ring (30), 1 Super Bowl MVP (8), 3 appearances (6), 2 playoff moment (16), playoff wins (11-4)(5), 1 criteria season w/playoffs(6) , 6 pro bowls(6), 1 passing record - 84
Eli Manning - 2 ring (20), 2 Super Bowl MVP(16), 2 appearance (4), 2 Playoff Moment(16), playoff wins (8-3), 2 criteria season, 1 criteria season w/playoffs (9), 2 pro bowls(2) = 75
Ben Roethlisberger - 2 rings(20), 3 appearances(6), 1 Playoff Moment(8), 2 criteria season; 1 criteria season w/playoffs(9), playoff wins (10-4), 2 pro bowls(2), 1 passing record (1) = 56
Joe Theisman – playoff wins (6-2), 1 Rings (10), 1 league MVP (6), 2 playoff moments (16) , 1 Super bowl Appearances (2), 2 probowls (2), 1 criteria seasons w/playoffs (6) - 48
Joe Flacco- 1 Ring (10), 1 Super Bowl MVP (8), 1 appearance(2), 1 Playoff Moment (8), playoff wins (9-4) – 37
Matt Ryan - 1 playoff moment (8), playoff wins (1-4), 3 criteria season, 3 criteria season w/playoffs (18), 2 pro bowl(2) = 29
Philip Rivers - 1 playoff Moment(8), playoff wins (3-4), 3 criteria seasons & 2 criteria seasons w/playoffs (12), 4 pro bowls(4) = 27
Michael Vick - 1 playoff Moment(8), playoff wins (2-4), 1 criteria season w/playoffs(6), 4 pro bowls(4), 3 passing records (Using 3 of His Rushing Records) = 23
Tony Romo - playoff win (1-3), 3 criteria season; 2 criteria season w/playoffs (15), 3 pro bowls (3) = 19
Matt Hasselbeck - 1 criteria season,1 Super Bowl Appearance(2) 1 criteria sason w/ playoffs(6), 5 playoff wins (5-6), 3 pro bowls(3) = 16
Carson Palmer - 2 criteria season, 1 criteria season w/playoffs(9), 2 pro bowls(2) = 11
Matthew Stafford - 1 criteria season w/playoffs(6) = 6
Tied 13) RG3 - 1 criteria season based on running and passing w/playoffs (6)
Matt Schaub - 1 criteria season (3), 1 pro bowl (1), Playoff Win (1-0) - 5
Mark Sanchez - 4 playoff wins (4-2) - 4
Cam Newton – playoff wins (0-0), 1 criteria season based on running and passing, one record based on QB td rushing record – 4
No comments:
Post a Comment